The article from the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) on the new Alzheimer’s treatment donanemab highlights several key points regarding the decision not to recommend this drug for use in the NHS. Essentially, donanemab has faced rejection due to concerns over its cost-effectiveness and the limited benefits it provides.
Reason for the Donanemab NHS rejection
NICE has determined that donanemab “does not currently demonstrate value for the NHS.” The NHS based this decision primarily on the drug’s cost-effectiveness; they saw its benefits to patients as too minimal to warrant the significant additional costs. The cost-effectiveness estimate for donanemab is five to six times above the threshold that NICE typically considers acceptable for NHS resources.
Clinical Benefits
While donanemab, manufactured by Eli Lilly, has shown potential to slow cognitive decline in Alzheimer’s patients, the observed benefits are relatively small. Clinical trials indicate that donanemab could result in a delay of cognitive decline by four to seven months. However, NICE’s independent committee concluded that this improvement is not adequate to justify the high costs associated with the treatment.
Regulatory Approval
Despite NICE’s decision, donanemab has received approval from the UK’s medicines regulator, the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA), for use within the UK. This approval is significant as it highlights the drug’s safety and efficacy, but it does not change NICE’s assessment regarding its cost-effectiveness for NHS use.
Impact on Patients and Carers
The rejection of donanemab for NHS use is a considerable setback for patients with early-stage Alzheimer’s and their carers. Advocates argue that drugs like donanemab, along with another rejected treatment called lecanemab, represent the first chance to effectively slow the decline in memory and cognitive abilities associated with Alzheimer’s, rather than merely addressing symptoms. Consequently, the decision may restrict access to these therapies to individuals who can afford private treatment.
Future Implications
This decision raises alarms that the UK could become a less appealing market for launching new dementia treatments due to strict cost-effectiveness standards. Organizations such as Alzheimer’s Research UK and various charities have urged the Health Secretary to take action and initiate discussions among NICE, NHS England, and the pharmaceutical industry. Policymakers aim to ensure that patients with dementia can access new treatments and receive proper attention in the healthcare system.
Ongoing Research and Development
NICE acknowledges that this is an emerging area of medicine and that further treatments are currently being researched. The agency emphasizes that more comprehensive evidence is needed on the clinical and cost-effectiveness of donanemab, suggesting that future reassessments could occur if additional data become available.
