NICE Collaborates with Menarini to Evaluate Elacestrant Breast Cancer Treatment

By João L. Carapinha

October 10, 2024

The article from the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) titled “NICE ready to work with company to address uncertainty in evidence for elacestrant for advanced breast cancer” highlights crucial details regarding the evaluation and potential use of elacestrant breast cancer therapy. Elacestrant is specifically under review for its effectiveness in treating oestrogen receptor-positive, human epidermal growth factor receptor 2-negative (HER2-), locally advanced or metastatic breast cancer with an activating ESR1 mutation, which complicates hormone therapies.

Key Points

Condition and Treatment

– Elacestrant is being considered for treating oestrogen receptor-positive, HER2-negative, locally advanced or metastatic breast cancer with an activating ESR1 mutation. This particular mutation can cause hormone therapies to stop working, leading to cancer progression.

Mechanism of Action

– As an oestrogen receptor degrader, elacestrant binds to and degrades oestrogen receptors, blocking oestrogen’s ability to bind to breast cancer cells and promote their growth.

Draft Guidance

– NICE has issued draft guidance that does not currently recommend elacestrant for this type of advanced breast cancer due to uncertainty in the evidence. This draft is open for public consultation until 22 October 2024.

Evidence and Uncertainty

– The evidence indicates that elacestrant may improve the time before the breast cancer worsens compared to standard care. However, there is considerable uncertainty surrounding these estimates. NICE has requested further analysis from the company to clarify and address this uncertainty.

Patient Eligibility

– It is estimated that about 1,000 individuals could be eligible for treatment with elacestrant breast cancer therapy.

Use of Severity Modifier

– NICE is examining whether to apply a severity modifier, which would give additional weight to the benefits of medicines based on the severity of the disease. This evaluation will continue at the committee’s next meeting on 12 November 2024.

Company and Stakeholders

– The company involved, Menarini Stemline, is collaborating with NICE to address the uncertainties in the evidence for elacestrant. Various patient, carer, and professional groups are also participating in the consultation process.

Context of Previous Recommendations

– Historically, around three-quarters (76%) of topics that were not initially recommended by NICE at the draft stage ended up receiving a positive recommendation before the final guidance was published. This trend suggests that there remains a potential for elacestrant to be recommended if the uncertainties can be successfully resolved.

Reference url

Recent Posts

CAPVAXIVE Pneumococcal Vaccine Delivers Strong Immune Response in At-Risk Youth

By HEOR Staff Writer

September 17, 2025

What makes the CAPVAXIVE pneumococcal vaccine significant for children and adolescents at higher risk for pneumococcal disease? The CAPVAXIVE pneumococcal vaccine (21-valent conjugate vaccine) demonstrated robust immune responses and broad serotype coverage in Merck’s Phase 3 STRIDE-13 trial. ...
Oral Semaglutide Benefits: EMA Approves First Oral GLP-1 RA with Cardiovascular Perks

By HEOR Staff Writer

September 16, 2025

Novo Nordisk’s oral semaglutide (Rybelsus®) has received a significant label update from the European Medicines Agency (EMA). It is now the first and only oral glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor agonist (GLP-1 RA) approved in the EU for type 2 diabetes with proven cardiovascular benefits. This deci...
Ending Unproven Fertility Treatments: NICE Calls for Evidence-Based Care in Clinics

By João L. Carapinha

September 10, 2025

Unproven fertility treatments—a term referring to add-on procedures without robust clinical evidence—have come under renewed scrutiny in the UK. Many prospective parents want to know: Why are unproven fertility treatments being discouraged, and what does this mean for fertility clinic choices...