Medical Device Procurement: Unravelling the Role of Health Technology Assessment

By Danélia Botes

November 13, 2023

The Current State of Health Technology Assessment

Health technology assessment (HTA) in medical device procurement has been instrumental in determining the value of medical devices. However, the unique characteristics of these devices, including frequent iterations and user learning curves, make generalising outcomes challenging. Furthermore, the diverse needs of stakeholders often result in varying views on a technology’s value. Despite the wealth of information available on HTA, a knowledge gap exists regarding its use by non-payer, non-HTA stakeholders in their assessment of medical devices.

Addressing the Gap: The ISPOR Special Interest Group Study

In an attempt to bridge this gap, the ISPOR Medical Devices and Diagnostics Special Interest Group conducted a systematic literature review. These studies were geographically diverse, originating from various locations globally. Two studies each were conducted in the United States, the United Kingdom, and Canada. Other studies were based in Italy, Australia, and South Africa. This review aimed to summarise the current evidence base for the criteria used in medical device procurement.A key finding across all studies was the utilisation of decision-making criteria that are generally considered standard elements of HTA. The most common criteria included cost (reported in 100% of the studies), safety (91%), efficacy (82%), cost-effectiveness (64%), and budget impact (36%). The results, however, showed sparse evidence regarding HTA’s use in device purchasing, making it difficult to draw firm conclusions about HTA’s impact on procurement.

Health Technology Assessment in Medical Device Procurement

The use and impact of HTA on treatment decisions vary widely across different geographies, further complicating the process. However, a growing trend towards “mini” or hospital-level HTA, which directly informs procurement decisions, has been observed. Most hospital-level HTA studies reviewed continue to depend on national-level HTA. They also use published systematic reviews to shape their conclusions.

The ISPOR Special Interest Group anticipates that HTA has more impact than their findings suggest, possibly due to a lack of publication incentive among procurement bodies. We need to deepen our research to comprehend the relationship between HTA and procurement better. Encouraging broader, more systemic evidence-based decision making also requires our attention. 

 

Reference url

Recent Posts

South African National Health Insurance Bill
          

High Court on South African National Health Insurance Bill

📢Latest update on the NHI! 📢 Dive into our latest piece on the judicial review of the South African National Health Insurance Bill. Learn about the intriguing case and its implications on the healthcare industry. 🏛️💼💡 #HealthcarePolicy #LegalReview #NationalHealthInsuranceBill

Global Perspective on Orphan Medicines
                

A Global Perspective on Orphan Medicines and Rare Diseases

Discover the global perspective on orphan medicines and their role in treating rare diseases. Learn about the unique challenges and incentives in their development. 🌍💊 #OrphanMedicines #RareDiseases #HealthcareInnovation #RareDiseaseDay. Read more here

            

The Impact of Universal Health Coverage on Poverty Reduction in Low and Middle-Income Countries

📚 New research findings alert! 🚨 A recent study shows that increasing coverage of maternal, child and inpatient services is associated with reduced poverty in low and middle-income countries. 💡 This supports pro-poor approaches towards Universal Health Coverage. 🌍 Let’s work together to ensure #HealthForAll and #EndPoverty. Read more here 📖 #UHC #GlobalHealth #HealthEquity

When you partner with Syenza, it’s like a Nuclear Fusion.

Our expertise are combined with yours, and we contribute clinical expertise and advanced degrees in health policy, health economics, systems analysis, public finance, business, and project management. You’ll also feel our high-impact global and local perspectives with cultural intelligence.

SPEAK WITH US

CORRESPONDENCE ADDRESS

1950 W. Corporate Way, Suite 95478
Anaheim, CA 92801, USA

JOIN NEWSLETTER




SERVICES

© 2024 Syenza™. All rights reserved.