Cost-Effective CML Treatment in South Africa

By Crystal Lubbe

January 30, 2025

The study by Woudberg and Sinanovic evaluates the cost-effectiveness of different tyrosine kinase inhibitor (TKI) treatment strategies for chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) in South Africa. It examines cost-effective treatment options using a Markov model to compare the effectiveness and costs of imatinib, nilotinib, and dasatinib as first-line treatments over a 20-year period. The results indicate that imatinib is the most cost-effective option, offering lower costs and acceptable quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) compared to nilotinib and dasatinib, which exceed the willingness-to-pay threshold.

Key Insights

Imatinib emerges as the dominant strategy due to its lower costs and generic availability, making it a more cost-effective CML treatment than nilotinib and dasatinib.
Nilotinib and dasatinib incur higher expenses and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) that surpass the willingness-to-pay threshold. This renders them less cost-effective as first-line treatments. The probabilistic sensitivity analysis confirms the robustness of the results, showing that imatinib remains the most cost-effective strategy across various scenarios. The high costs associated with nilotinib and dasatinib place significant pressure on the limited resources of the South African healthcare system. This situation highlights the need for price negotiations or alternative funding mechanisms to enhance access to these treatments.

Background Context

The introduction of TKIs has transformed CML from a fatal disease to a manageable condition with significantly improved life expectancy. However, the cost-effectiveness of these treatments varies by country due to differing healthcare systems and economic conditions. In South Africa, CML patients are diagnosed at a younger age compared to global averages. The healthcare system faces challenges such as treatment interruptions, limited adherence, and long travel distances to healthcare facilities, all of which adversely affect treatment outcomes. The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends using one to three times the GDP per capita as a willingness-to-pay threshold for cost-effectiveness evaluations. In this study, they defined the threshold as three times South Africa’s GDP per capita.

Implications

The study emphasises the necessity of conducting country-specific economic evaluations to inform healthcare policy and resource allocation. Imatinib’s cost-effectiveness emphasises the importance of generic or affordable versions of TKIs in managing CML in resource-limited settings.

The findings highlight the need to address systemic challenges such as poor adherence, treatment interruptions, and limited access to second-line treatments and stem cell transplantation. These factors are crucial for optimising CML treatment outcomes in South Africa. Policymakers must carefully consider the financial implications of incorporating second-generation TKIs into routine care. To improve access to these treatments, they should explore strategies such as price negotiations or alternative funding mechanisms. This approach ensures that South Africa allocate resources efficiently to maximise health benefits.

Reference url

Recent Posts

Social Media Policy Action: Protecting Youth from Cognitive Risks

By João L. Carapinha

October 16, 2025

A recent editorial published in JAMA emphasizes the urgent need for social media policy action due to the developmental impacts of social media on youth. The article discusses a pivotal study by Nagata et al., which examined a large cohort of adolescents. This study revealed that increas...
Johnson & Johnson Advances Solid Tumor Research at ESMO 2025 with Promising New Data
Johnson & Johnson has announced promising new data across multiple solid tumor types, which will be presented at the European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO) 2025 Congress in Berlin, and the company describes this as "a new era" in their solid tumor research. The press release highlights ...
Colorectal Cancer Markers: Discovering Region-Specific Drivers for Precision Oncology

By HEOR Staff Writer

October 15, 2025

Colorectal cancer markers like NOX1 and NPY1R are changing the way experts diagnose and manage colon cancer. But how do these region-specific markers impact colorectal cancer detection, prognosis, and personalized therapies? Recent breakthroughs show that understanding where a tumor begins—with t...